| 1991 Marilyn "Lou" Phelan | |
| 1992 Theresa Spears | |
| 1993 Margaret "Betty" Martin | |
| 1994 Stephanie Spears | |
| 1995 Jacquie Spaulding | |
| 1996 Mary Beth Ryan | |
| 1997 Betty Rohman | |
| 1998 Colleen Sullivan | |
| 1999 JoAnn Martin | |
| 2000 Ann O'Neill | |
| 2001 Eileen O'Connell | |
| 2002 Trish Flynn | |
| 2003 Jo Jordan | |
| 2004 Jolene Doyle | |
| 2005 Kay Bergquist | |
| 2006 Beth Haney | |
| 2007 Dorothy Kendall | |